ShareThis Page
‘Batman v Superman’ draws battle lines among fans |

‘Batman v Superman’ draws battle lines among fans

Paul Schofield
| Wednesday, March 23, 2016 9:00 p.m
Clay Enos
Ben Affleck as Batman and Henry Cavill as Superman
Warner Bros.
Promotional poster for 'Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice:
Photograph: Zack Snyder
Ben Affleck as Batman
Warner Bros.
Gal Gadot plays Wonder Woman in 'Batman v Superman'
Warner Bros.
Henry Cavill reprises his role of Superman.
Warner Bros.
Jesse Eisenberg as Lex Luthor and Amy Adams as Lois Lane in 'Batman v Superman'
Warner Bros.
Henry Cavill as Clark Kent, Jesse Eisenber as Lex Luthor and Ben Affleck as Bruce Wayne in 'Batman v Superman'
Warner Bros.
Henry Cavill as Clark Kent, Jesse Eisenber as Lex Luthor and Ben Affleck as Bruce Wayne in 'Batman v Superman'
Warner Bros.
Gal Gadot plays Wonder Woman in 'Batman v Superman'

Pundits are making predictions, debates are degrading into wrestling matches, and Facebook friendships are breaking up. All over one question: Who would win: Batman or Superman?

The debate has been raging for 70 years and is the premise for the soon-to-be-released film “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice.”

For some, it’s a philosophical question. The choice between good vs. evil is an obvious one. But, when confronted with good vs. good, we are burdened with the moral imperative of choosing the greater of two goods.

In the 2013 movie “Man of Steel,” Superman was presented as a saviorlike character with supernatural powers sent from another world to act as our benevolent protector. As the classic TV show introduction once said, he represents “truth, justice and the American Way.”

Batman, on the other hand, represents a Chaotic Good, enforcing justice with a disregard for society’s rules. He prefers a self-reliant approach representing a secular humanism grounded in science and technology.

They are, literally, from two different worlds, as manifested by their sources of power: Superman’s strengths derive from Earth’s yellow sun, and Batman thrives in the darkness and shadows.

The battle represents the struggle of man’s Id and Superego. … Who are we kidding? We just want to see two guys in tights beat each other up! So, who would win?

Andrew Farago, curator of the Cartoon Art Museum of San Francisco, insists, “It’s not even close. Superman wins. It’s like asking who would win in a foot race between Usain Bolt and a baked potato.”

Albeit, a well-armed and physically fit baked potato.

Melanie Bolen, a self-professed comics geek and a health and fitness trainer from Chicago, is also with Team Superman.

“I don’t see how it could even be a fair fight if Superman has his powers,” she says. “Both may be physically fit, but Superman holds the edge even with less muscle mass than Batman.”

Superman’s powers make him an overwhelming opponent, unbeatable in a fair fight. But why fight fair?

“Frank Miller’s classic ‘Dark Knight Returns’ leveled the playing field by having a severely weakened Superman going up against Batman, who didn’t expect to survive the fight,” Farago says.

At least one expert thinks Batman could best the Man of Steel.

Suveen Mathaudhu is a former materials engineer with the Army Research Laboratory Weapons and Materials Research Directorate. He once got into an argument with famed astrophysicist and fellow comic-book nerd, Neil DeGrasse Tyson, over the weight of Thor’s hammer. Mathaudhu won.

“In my prior experience in the Department of Defense, we frequently refer to ‘asymmetrical warfare,’ where one side maintains dominance through the exploitation of the other’s obvious weaknesses,” Mathaudhu says. “Like real scientists, Batman does meticulous research on problems he has to solve and identifies the psychological/physical weaknesses of those he may need to defeat.”

According to Mathaudhu, the physical fight is pretty straightforward. “It’s all about one character trying to break the other via impact.” Batman’s goal is to “make armor strong enough to resist damage from Supes and make Supes more susceptible to damage.”

The Dark Knight will need to exploit Superman’s weaknesses by:

• Eliminating his “photonucleic” source of power (solar radiation).

• Using lead-lined armor to negate Superman’s laser vision.

• Taking advantage of emotional weakness: While both characters’ personal codes prevent them from killing, Superman was forced to kill the villain Zod in the previous film, “Man of Steel.” That weighs heavily on Superman and may make him hold back, giving Batman an edge.

• Then, of course, there is Superman’s Kryptonite. Kryptonite is the ultimate “cheat code” to beating Superman. It weakens him to the point of absolute defenselessness.

• The winner in a battle of the “good guys” may hinge upon who is willing to be the bad guy. Bolen sums it up best: “In that case, Batman wins, because he’d totally fight dirtier!”

Ultimately, the entire battle may be anti-climactic, as Batman and the Big Blue Boy Scout will make amends to join the Justice League in a movie that is slated for release in November 2017.

Cartoon artist Joe Wos is a Tribune-Review contributing writer.

The Matchup


Aka: The Man of Steel, The Big Blue Boy Scout

Secret identity: Clark Kent, reporter for the Daily Planet

Home base: Metropolis

First appeared: Action Comics #1, June 1938

Created by: Jerry Seigel and Joe Shuster

Superpowers: Flight, speed, stamina, X-ray vision, heat vision, invulnerability, superhuman strength and endurance, super-hearing and super-breath

Weaknesses: Kryptonite and red sun radiation


Aka: The Dark Knight

Secret identity: Bruce Wayne, billionaire playboy and philanthropist

Home base: Gotham City

First appeared: Detective Comics #27, May 1939

Created by: Bob Kane and Bill Finger

Superpowers: None

Skills: Intellect, forensics, scientific knowledge, engineering, hand-to-hand combat, physical strength, endurance, stealth and advanced weaponry

Weaknesses: Human limitations

Other comic-book hero battles

Captain America vs. Iron Man: “Civil War #7” (2007). Winner: Captain America

Batman vs. Punisher: “Punisher/Batman: Deadly Knights” (1994). Winner: Batman

Superman vs. The Amazing Spider-Man: “Superman vs. The Amazing Spider-Man: The Battle of the Century” (1976). Winner: Draw

Hulk vs. The Thing: “Fantastic Four #25-26” (1964). Winner: Hulk

Thor vs. Silver Surfer: “Silver Surfer #4” (1969). Winner: Draw

Hulk vs. Wolverine: “Incredible Hulk #181” (1974). Winner: Hulk

Superman vs. Muhammad Ali: “Superman vs. Muhammad Ali #C-56” (1978). Winner: Muhammad Ali (by a knockout, of course)

Paul Schofield is a Tribune-Review sports reporter. You can contact Paul by email at or via Twitter .

Categories: Movies TV
TribLIVE commenting policy

You are solely responsible for your comments and by using you agree to our Terms of Service.

We moderate comments. Our goal is to provide substantive commentary for a general readership. By screening submissions, we provide a space where readers can share intelligent and informed commentary that enhances the quality of our news and information.

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderating decisions are subjective. We will make them as carefully and consistently as we can. Because of the volume of reader comments, we cannot review individual moderation decisions with readers.

We value thoughtful comments representing a range of views that make their point quickly and politely. We make an effort to protect discussions from repeated comments either by the same reader or different readers

We follow the same standards for taste as the daily newspaper. A few things we won't tolerate: personal attacks, obscenity, vulgarity, profanity (including expletives and letters followed by dashes), commercial promotion, impersonations, incoherence, proselytizing and SHOUTING. Don't include URLs to Web sites.

We do not edit comments. They are either approved or deleted. We reserve the right to edit a comment that is quoted or excerpted in an article. In this case, we may fix spelling and punctuation.

We welcome strong opinions and criticism of our work, but we don't want comments to become bogged down with discussions of our policies and we will moderate accordingly.

We appreciate it when readers and people quoted in articles or blog posts point out errors of fact or emphasis and will investigate all assertions. But these suggestions should be sent via e-mail. To avoid distracting other readers, we won't publish comments that suggest a correction. Instead, corrections will be made in a blog post or in an article.